Board Review of Challenged Books - Completed Reviews

The books below were selected by the Library Board of Trustees to review at the regular board meetings based on the appeal of the Library Director's decisions, which are linked in the far right column.  The challenger's name has been removed for patron privacy.

Details about this process have been included in previous month's board packets and additional information links

Key: 

Retain=The board votes to retain the book as noted in the Letter from the Library Director. 
Label= The board votes to add a Sexually Explicit Label to the item.
Move= The board votes to move the item to the Adult Collection.

Library CollectionTitle, AuthorRequest for Reconsideration FormLetter from Library DirectorTrustee decisions: (date)
Teen Graphic NovelAs the Crow Flies, by GillmanRequest for Reconsideration for As the Crow FliesRegarding: As the Crow FliesRetain (2/19)
 Cheer Up! Love and Pom PomsChallenge and response to Cheer Up! Retain (2/19)
Juvenile Graphic Novel
Dog Knight, by Whitley

 		Request for Reconsideration for Dog KnightRegarding: Dog KnightRetain (2/19)
Juvenile Graphic NovelGrace needs Space, by Wilgus

 		Request for Reconsideration for Grace Needs SpaceRegarding: Grace Needs SpaceRetain (2/19)
Teen Graphic NovelHarley Quinn: Breaking GlassChallenge and Response to Harley Quinn: Breaking Glass Retain (2/19)
 Kisses for JetChallenge and Response to Kisses for Jet Retain (2/19)
 Liberated: The Radical Art and Life of Claude CahunChallenge and Response to Liberated Retain (2/19)
Adult Non-Fiction Gender Your Guide, by AirtonRequest for Reconsideration for Gender your GuideRegarding: Gender Your GuideRetain (1/15/26)
Teen Fiction Bianca Torree is Afraid of Everything, by Winans Request for Reconsideration for Bianca Torre is AfraidRegarding: Bianca Torre is AfraidRetain (1/15/26)
Teen Non-FictionBeyond Magenta, by KuklinRequest for Reconsideration for Beyond MagentaRegarding: Beyond MagentaLabel- addition of Sexually Explicit Label (12/18/25)
ParentingBeing you a First conversation about Gender, by Madison (board book)
 		Request for Reconsideration for Being YouRegarding: Being You Retain (12/18/25)
Juvenile Picture BookBig wig, by HillmanRequest for Reconsideration for Big WigRegarding: Big WigRetain (12/18/25)
Juvenile Picture BookDaddy and Dada, by BrockingtonRequest for Reconsideration for Daddy and DadaRegarding: Daddy and DadaRetain (12/18/25)
Juvenile Picture BookFamily Book, by Parr
 		Request for Reconsideration for The Family BookRegarding: Family BookRetain (12/18/25)
Juvenile Picture Book
I’m not a girl a transgender story, by Lyons

 		Request for Reconsideration for I'm not a GirlRegarding: I'm not a GirlRetain (12/18/25)
(if ever acquired)
Juvenile Picture BookLove Violet, by WildRequest for Reconsideration for Love, VioletRegarding: Love, VioletRetain (12/18/25)
Juvenile Picture BookPeanut Goes for Gold, by Van NessRequest for Reconsideration for Peanut Goes for the GoldRegarding: Peanut Retain (12/18/25)
Juvenile Picture BookPlenty of Hugs, by Manushkin
 		Request for Reconsideration for Plenty of HugsRegarding: Plenty of HugsRetain (12/18/25)
Juvenile Picture Book
What are your words a book about pronouns, by  Locke
 		Request for Reconsideration for What are Your Words?Regarding: What are your Words?Retain (12/18/25)
Juvenile Picture BookWorm loves Worm, by AustrianRequest for Reconsideration for Worm loves WormRegarding: Worm Loves WormRetain (12/18/25)